OnCo
termsTerm

Non-inferiority trial

aka non-inferiority, noninferiority, non-inferior, noninferior, non-inferiority margin, non-inferiority trial, non-inferiority design, met non-inferiority, superiority, superiority trial, superiority design, equivalence, equivalence trial

A trial designed to show a new treatment is not meaningfully worse than the standard, rather than better: used when the new option is shorter, cheaper, less toxic or easier (five radiotherapy fractions instead of 25, six months of trastuzumab instead of twelve).

The sponsor pre-specifies a non-inferiority margin (the largest loss of efficacy considered acceptable, e.g. a hazard ratio upper confidence limit below 1.2) and the trial succeeds if the confidence interval excludes that margin. Because a bad trial (poor adherence, wrong population) tends toward no difference, non-inferiority trials must be run rigorously and are analysed per-protocol as well as intention-to-treat. They underpin most de-escalation (hypofractionation, IDEA 3 vs 6 months FOLFOX, PERSEPHONE, segmentectomy vs lobectomy, SANO active surveillance) and biosimilar approvals. Choosing the margin is contentious: a 'non-inferior' result can still mean some patients are harmed.

Category
Trials & regulation

Connected

7top