OnCo
bottlenecksBottleneck

Pain relief and palliative care are unavailable to most

Most people who die of cancer worldwide do so without adequate pain relief.

Palliative care improves quality of life, reduces depression and, in at least one landmark randomised trial, lengthened survival when introduced at diagnosis of metastatic lung cancer, yet WHO estimates that only about 14% of people who need palliative care worldwide receive it. Access to opioids, the essential and inexpensive treatment for cancer pain, is restricted in most low- and middle-income countries by regulation, fear of diversion, and lack of trained prescribers, so that the poorest half of the world uses a tiny fraction of the morphine-equivalent opioids consumed by the richest countries. Even in high-income systems, palliative care is introduced late, often in the last weeks of life, and is still confused with hospice. The Lancet Commission's essential package of palliative care costs a few dollars per capita; the bottleneck is policy, training and the position of palliative care within oncology, not science.

majoraccess delivery17 ideas to fix it
How big the problem is
~14%
People who need palliative care worldwide who receive it (WHO estimate)
More than 25 million (2015)
People who die each year with serious health-related suffering, most in low- and middle-income countries
11.6 vs 8.9 months
Median overall survival with early palliative care vs standard care in metastatic NSCLC
Root causes
  • Opioid regulations designed to prevent diversion block legitimate medical use in most low- and middle-income countries.
  • Palliative care is not integrated into oncology training or cancer plans in many countries.
  • Clinicians and patients equate palliative care with giving up, so referral happens late.
  • Palliative services are funded poorly relative to disease-directed treatment.
  • Workforce shortages leave no one to prescribe, dispense or deliver home-based care.
What is already being tried
  • The Lancet Commission on Global Access to Palliative Care and Pain Relief defined an essential package and costed it for low- and middle-income countries.
  • World Health Assembly resolution WHA67.19 (2014) commits member states to integrate palliative care into health systems.
  • Hospice Africa Uganda's affordable oral morphine model has been adopted across several African countries.
  • ASCO's clinical practice guideline (2017) recommends integration of palliative care with standard oncology care from diagnosis of advanced cancer.
  • ESMO Designated Centres of Integrated Oncology and Palliative Care accredit hospitals that embed palliative care within oncology.
  • The International Narcotics Control Board and WHO work with countries to balance opioid availability with control.
What breaking it looks like
Every country has oral morphine available and prescribed for cancer pain, palliative care is introduced at diagnosis of incurable disease as a routine part of oncology, and the share of people with serious health-related suffering who receive palliative care exceeds 80%.

Ideas to fix it

17top
early clinicalphilanthropymedium cost
A paediatric palliative care team in every childhood cancer unit

Children with cancer, and their families, need symptom relief and support from diagnosis, not only at the end. Every children's cancer unit should have a palliative team, and most in poorer countries have none.

being tested at scaleclinicsmall cost
Algorithm-triggered goals-of-care conversations before crisis

When a prediction model says a patient has a high chance of dying within a year, their team is prompted to have a structured conversation about what matters to them, while there is still time to act on it.

being tested at scaleclinicsmall cost
Automatic palliative care referral triggered by diagnosis, not by decline

Palliative care given from the start of treatment for advanced cancer improves quality of life and may extend it. Instead of waiting for an oncologist to remember, the system should refer automatically when the diagnosis is recorded.

early clinicalclinicsmall cost
Community health workers trained in cancer triage, navigation and home palliative care

Millions of community health workers already visit homes for vaccines and maternal care. Training them to recognise cancer warning signs, guide patients through the system and support home pain care would reach people no hospital does.

speculativepolicymedium cost
Earmark a fixed share of every national cancer budget for palliative care

Most of the money in cancer goes to treatments that help a few people for a short time, while pain relief for the dying, which is cheap and works, gets almost nothing. Ring-fencing a small fixed share would change that.

early clinicalphilanthropysmall cost
Home end-of-life care kits and trained family carers where no hospice exists

Most people in poorer countries die at home without any professional support. A simple kit of medicines and supplies plus a few hours of training for a family member could make dying far less painful.

being tested at scalepolicysmall cost
Locally prepared oral morphine solution, licensed for nurse prescribing

Uganda makes liquid morphine from powder in a simple facility and lets trained nurses prescribe it, giving pain relief to patients that no doctor will ever reach. Other countries could copy this within a year.

speculativepolicysmall cost
Measure and publish pain control rates in every cancer centre

Hospitals publish survival and infection rates but almost never how many of their cancer patients are in uncontrolled pain. Measuring and publishing it would make pain a priority.

being tested at scalepolicysmall cost
National opioid quota reform so morphine reaches cancer patients

Most of the world's people who die in cancer pain have no access to morphine, a drug that costs pennies, because of restrictive national rules. Fixing the rules, not inventing new drugs, is the answer.

being tested at scalepolicylarge cost
Palliative care from diagnosis for every advanced cancer, including opioid access, worldwide

Palliative care given early alongside cancer treatment improves quality of life and sometimes survival, and most of the world has no access to it or to morphine. Make both universal.

speculativepolicymedium cost
Put the essential palliative care package into every universal health coverage benefit list

The Lancet Commission defined a cheap basic package of drugs, equipment and staff for palliative care. Countries expanding health coverage should include it as a guaranteed benefit.

being tested at scaleclinicsmall cost
Single-fraction radiotherapy as the default for painful bone metastases

One radiotherapy session relieves bone pain as well as ten, according to many trials, yet most patients still get the longer course. Making one session the default would spare patients trips and free machines.

being tested at scaleclinicsmall cost
Train every oncology team in serious-illness conversations and prompt them in the record

Patients with advanced cancer often never have a clear conversation about what to expect and what matters to them. A structured conversation guide, taught to clinicians and prompted by the record, makes these talks happen earlier.

speculativeclinicsmall cost
Treat wasting like sepsis: a trigger, a bundle, an audit

Hospitals have fast, standard responses to sepsis and heart attacks. Cancer wasting has no such pathway, so it is noticed late and treated inconsistently.

speculativeresearchmedium cost
Trials of low-cost opioid alternatives where morphine supply is unreliable

When morphine is unavailable, patients get nothing. Some cheap alternatives, such as methadone or tramadol, may work for cancer pain but have not been properly tested in these settings.

being tested at scalepayersmall cost
Video palliative care as an equivalent default option for patients far from a team

A large trial showed that palliative care delivered by video works as well as in person for people with advanced lung cancer. Payers should cover it so that distance from a hospital no longer decides who gets it.

being tested at scalepatientssmall cost
Volunteer-led neighbourhood palliative networks, the Kerala model, adapted elsewhere

In Kerala, trained community volunteers, backed by nurses and doctors, provide most home palliative care to the dying. The model reaches more people at lower cost than any clinic-based service and could be copied.

What relieves it today

1top

Key papers

1top

Connected

37top

cancers

7

fronts

1

technologies

1

institutions

6

ideas

17

collections

1

people

3

key papers

1