HR-positive / HER2-negative breast cancer: guideline history
6 dated versions from 2017 to 2025 listing 10 changes. Pick two versions to see what changed between them; the timeline below shows every version with the event it is anchored to.
- RecategorisedMetastatic, HER2-low, chemotherapy-naiveTrastuzumab deruxtecan moved earlier: now an option after one or more endocrine lines and before chemotherapy in HER2-low and HER2-ultralow disease.after chemotherapy (DESTINY-Breast04) after endocrine therapy, before chemotherapy (DESTINY-Breast06)
- AddedAdjuvant, stage II-IIIRibociclib for 3 years with an aromatase inhibitor for stage II-III HR-positive early breast cancer, including node-negative high-risk disease.
- AddedMetastatic, PIK3CA-mutant, endocrine-resistantInavolisib plus palbociclib and fulvestrant for PIK3CA-mutated disease relapsing during or within 12 months of adjuvant endocrine therapy.
- AddedMetastatic, ESR1-mutantImlunestrant added as an oral SERD option for ESR1-mutated disease after endocrine therapy.
Timeline
Anchored to: FDA approvals of ribociclib (March 2017) and abemaciclib (September 2017) after palbociclib (2015)
- addedMetastatic, first line: All three CDK4/6 inhibitors with an aromatase inhibitor listed as category 1 first-line options.
Anchored to: FDA approval of adjuvant abemaciclib, October 2021 (monarchE)
- addedAdjuvant, high risk: Abemaciclib for 2 years with endocrine therapy for node-positive, high-risk HR-positive early breast cancer (initially Ki-67 20% or above, later removed).
Anchored to: Annals of Oncology publication, November 2021
- recategorisedMetastatic, first line: CDK4/6 inhibitor plus endocrine therapy stated as the standard first-line treatment for most patients; chemotherapy reserved for visceral crisis.option → standard of care [I, A]
- addedMetastatic, PIK3CA-mutant after endocrine therapy: Alpelisib plus fulvestrant for PIK3CA-mutated disease after aromatase inhibitor.
Anchored to: FDA approvals of elacestrant (January 2023) and capivasertib (November 2023)
- addedMetastatic, ESR1-mutant after CDK4/6: Elacestrant for ESR1-mutated disease after at least one line of endocrine therapy (EMERALD).
- addedMetastatic, PIK3CA/AKT1/PTEN-altered: Capivasertib plus fulvestrant after progression on an aromatase inhibitor (CAPItello-291).
Anchored to: FDA approvals of adjuvant ribociclib (September 2024, NATALEE) and inavolisib (October 2024, INAVO120)
- addedAdjuvant, stage II-III: Ribociclib for 3 years with an aromatase inhibitor for stage II-III HR-positive early breast cancer, including node-negative high-risk disease.
- addedMetastatic, PIK3CA-mutant, endocrine-resistant: Inavolisib plus palbociclib and fulvestrant for PIK3CA-mutated disease relapsing during or within 12 months of adjuvant endocrine therapy.
Anchored to: FDA approvals of trastuzumab deruxtecan for HER2-low or ultralow disease after endocrine therapy (January 2025, DESTINY-Breast06) and imlunestrant (September 2025, EMBER-3)
- recategorisedMetastatic, HER2-low, chemotherapy-naive: Trastuzumab deruxtecan moved earlier: now an option after one or more endocrine lines and before chemotherapy in HER2-low and HER2-ultralow disease.after chemotherapy (DESTINY-Breast04) → after endocrine therapy, before chemotherapy (DESTINY-Breast06)
- addedMetastatic, ESR1-mutant: Imlunestrant added as an oral SERD option for ESR1-mutated disease after endocrine therapy.
Where the bodies stand today
| Setting and intervention | NCCN | ESMO | NICE | ASCO | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
HR-positive / HER2-negative breast cancer · Metastatic, HER2-low, after chemotherapy Trastuzumab deruxtecan for HER2-low metastatic breast cancer after one chemotherapy (DESTINY-Breast04) | Preferred Category 1, preferred 2022-08 | Recommended I, A; ESMO-MCBS 4 2023 | Not recommended 2024 | Recommended 2023 | Bodies disagree |
HR-positive / HER2-negative breast cancer · Adjuvant, high risk Abemaciclib for 2 years with endocrine therapy (monarchE) | Recommended Category 1 2021-10 | Recommended I, A; ESMO-MCBS A 2024-02 | Recommended TA810 2022-07 | Recommended 2022 | Bodies agree |
Other cancers
Each entry is anchored to a dated public event and links to the guideline body’s page for the disease; NCCN “Summary of changes” pages sit behind a free login and are not reproduced. Version labels say “update” where the NCCN version number has not been verified. Corrections are welcome via the repository.