OnCo
bottlenecksBottleneck

The brain: barrier and sanctuary

Most drugs cannot cross into the brain, so brain tumours and brain metastases lag every other site.

The blood-brain barrier excludes most large molecules and many small ones by tight junctions and active efflux, so antibodies, ADCs and many kinase inhibitors reach the brain at a fraction of plasma concentration. Glioblastoma median survival with the Stupp regimen has been about 15 months since 2005 and no drug since has meaningfully moved it; temozolomide, lomustine and tumour-treating fields remain the standard, with vorasidenib the first real advance in a decade for IDH-mutant low-grade glioma. Brain metastases develop in around a fifth of adults with cancer, are excluded or under-represented in most systemic-therapy trials, and are usually managed with radiotherapy alone. Newer agents (tucatinib, osimertinib, lorlatinib, trastuzumab deruxtecan) show that CNS activity is achievable when designed for; focused ultrasound, convection-enhanced delivery, intrathecal cell therapy and receptor-mediated transcytosis are the delivery technologies under test.

majorbiology17 ideas to fix it
How big the problem is
14.6 months
Median overall survival in newly diagnosed glioblastoma with radiotherapy plus temozolomide (Stupp regimen), still the standard of care
~20%
Adults with cancer who develop brain metastases
20.9 vs 16.0 months
Median overall survival with tumour-treating fields added to temozolomide (EF-14), the only phase 3 survival gain in glioblastoma since 2005
Root causes
  • Tight endothelial junctions and P-glycoprotein efflux exclude most antibodies, ADCs and many small molecules.
  • Glioma cells infiltrate diffusely along white-matter tracts, so surgery and focal radiotherapy cannot remove them all.
  • Patients with brain metastases are excluded from most trials, so CNS activity is rarely measured until after approval.
  • Glioma is immunologically cold and the brain has limited lymphatic drainage, blunting immunotherapy.
  • Tumour heterogeneity in glioblastoma is extreme and single-target agents (EGFRvIII vaccine) have failed.
What is already being tried
  • Insightec's MR-guided focused ultrasound transiently opens the blood-brain barrier and is in trials to deliver chemotherapy and antibodies to glioma.
  • HER2CLIMB and DESTINY-Breast12 show that tucatinib and trastuzumab deruxtecan have meaningful activity against HER2-positive brain metastases, changing trial eligibility norms.
  • INDIGO established vorasidenib for IDH-mutant grade 2 glioma, the first targeted therapy to delay progression in diffuse glioma.
  • Intraventricular and locoregional CAR-T (IL13Ra2, GD2 for H3K27M diffuse midline glioma) at City of Hope and Stanford bypass the barrier entirely.
  • Novocure's Optune tumour-treating fields device is approved for glioblastoma and is being tested in brain metastases and other sites.
  • The FDA and ASCO-Friends of Cancer Research recommendations now call for inclusion of patients with treated or stable brain metastases in trials.
What breaking it looks like
Median survival in glioblastoma exceeds three years in a phase 3 trial, and patients with brain metastases are routinely included in systemic-therapy trials with CNS response measured as a standard endpoint.

Ideas to fix it

17top
early clinicalindustrymedium cost
A skull ultrasound implant that opens the barrier at every cycle

A small ultrasound device implanted in the skull can be switched on at each chemotherapy visit to briefly open the brain barrier, letting drugs in every cycle.

early clinicalresearchlarge cost
A standard platform to get drugs into the brain: focused ultrasound plus shuttle-engineered therapeutics

Most cancer drugs cannot cross into the brain. Combine ultrasound that briefly opens the barrier with drugs engineered to be carried across, and make this a standard platform for every brain tumour and brain metastasis.

early clinicalregulatorsmall cost
Brain metastases included by default in every solid-tumour trial

Up to a fifth of people with advanced solid tumours have cancer in the brain and are usually barred from trials. Letting in those whose brain disease is treated, stable or symptom-free would widen trials and tell us whether drugs work in the brain.

preclinical evidenceengineeringmedium cost
Build a human model of the barrier that guards the brain fluid

Drugs that reach brain tissue may still fail to reach the fluid where cancer spreads along the linings. A lab model of that second barrier would let us screen for drugs that cross it.

early clinicalclinicmedium cost
Deliver CAR-T cells straight into the fluid around the brain

Cancer spreading along the linings of the brain is almost untreatable. Injecting engineered immune cells directly into the brain fluid, through a small reservoir, reaches it.

preclinical evidenceresearchmedium cost
Deliver drugs and cells to the brain through the nose

The nerves at the top of the nose lead directly into the brain, bypassing the barrier. Nasal delivery of drugs, and even immune cells, has worked in animals.

preclinical evidenceindustrymedium cost
Design protein degraders small enough to get into the brain

New drugs that destroy cancer proteins are usually too big to enter the brain. Making much smaller versions could bring this approach to brain tumours.

early clinicalindustrymedium cost
Oncolytic viruses that make interleukin-12 only inside the tumour

Interleukin-12 is one of the most powerful immune stimulants but is too toxic to inject into the bloodstream. A virus can be engineered to make it only inside a tumour.

preclinical evidenceresearchmedium cost
Open the barrier so engineered immune cells can enter the brain

Engineered immune cells given by drip rarely reach brain tumours. Briefly opening the barrier with focused ultrasound at the right moment may let them in.

speculativeindustrylarge cost
Prevention trials aimed only at brain metastasis

Some cancers reach the brain in up to a quarter of patients. Prevention trials could aim specifically at stopping that, instead of treating it once it has happened.

early clinicalclinicsmall cost
Read the spinal fluid to track brain tumours without opening the skull

Fluid taken from the lower back contains DNA from brain tumours. Testing it can diagnose, monitor and detect resistance without brain surgery.

speculativepolicysmall cost
Require every oncology candidate to publish how much reaches the brain

Whether a drug gets into the brain is measured early in development but rarely published. Making that number public would show which existing drugs could treat brain disease.

early clinicalengineeringmedium cost
Robot-placed catheters and live imaging for drug infusion into brain tumours

Pumping drugs slowly through fine tubes into a brain tumour can bypass the barrier, but the fluid often leaks away. Robotic placement and live scans would show where it actually goes.

speculativeregulatorsmall cost
Stop excluding brain metastases from cancer trials

One in five people with advanced cancer has brain spread, yet most trials refuse them. Requiring brain cohorts would give those patients evidence instead of guesswork.

speculativeresearchlarge cost
Treat brain metastases as a disease with its own trials programme

A fifth of patients with solid tumours develop brain metastases and are usually excluded from trials. This would fund a programme that studies and treats them as a disease in their own right.

early clinicalengineeringmedium cost
Ultrasound-assisted blood test instead of a brain biopsy

Brain tumours shed very little DNA into blood, so a sonobiopsy briefly opens the brain's barrier with focused ultrasound to release enough to read from a blood sample.

preclinical evidenceindustrymedium cost
Use the brain's own transport door to carry antibody drugs across

The brain has natural transport doors for iron. Attaching a key that fits those doors can smuggle large drug molecules in, a trick now working in Alzheimer's medicines.

Key papers

4top
rctNew England Journal of Medicine 2023changed practice
INDIGO: vorasidenib, the first targeted drug for IDH-mutant low-grade glioma

Young adults with a grade 2 IDH-mutant glioma who have had surgery can now take a daily tablet that slows or reverses tumour growth and defers radiotherapy and chemotherapy, both of which carry long-term cognitive costs, by years. It confirms that the IDH mutation is a driver that can be targeted, not just a marker. Whether it improves survival or cognition over the long term, and whether it helps in higher-grade or previously treated tumours, is unknown.

rctNew England Journal of Medicine 2020changed practice
CROWN: lorlatinib versus crizotinib as first treatment for ALK-positive lung cancer

For ALK-positive advanced lung cancer, lorlatinib as the first drug offers the possibility of many years without progression and strong protection against brain metastases. Alectinib and brigatinib remain alternatives with a gentler side-effect profile; the choice weighs lorlatinib's cognitive, metabolic and weight effects against its unmatched duration of control.

rctNew England Journal of Medicine 2018changed practice
FLAURA: osimertinib as first treatment for EGFR-mutated lung cancer

Anyone diagnosed with advanced lung cancer should have EGFR testing before treatment, because osimertinib as the first drug gives the longest disease control, protects the brain, and is well tolerated. Chemotherapy is not the first step for these patients. The remaining questions are whether to intensify upfront (adding chemotherapy or amivantamab) and how to treat resistance when it develops.

rctNew England Journal of Medicine 2005changed practice
Stupp 2005: temozolomide added to radiotherapy for newly diagnosed glioblastoma

Patients with newly diagnosed glioblastoma who are fit and under about 70 receive six weeks of radiotherapy with daily temozolomide followed by six monthly cycles of temozolomide; this is still the backbone of treatment two decades later. Testing MGMT methylation identifies who benefits most and guides decisions in older patients. Median survival with the regimen remains only around 15-20 months, and no drug since has clearly improved on it, which is why glioblastoma is a priority for new approaches.

Connected

72top

Pages like this

not linked directly; found by shared links

cancers

5

technologies

7

targets

3

drugs

7

companies

3

institutions

9

pathways

1

terms

5

trials

7

ideas

21

key papers

4