Loading
In high-dose-rate brachytherapy a machine pushes a tiny, very radioactive source along tubes into the treatment area for a few minutes, then pulls it back into a shielded safe. You are alone in the room while it runs, but staff watch and talk to you throughout. The machine is checked every treatment day, and the team practises for the rare case the source does not go back.
An HDR or pulsed-dose-rate afterloader is checked before the first treatment of each day (IAEA SSG-46 para 5.134; US 10 CFR 35.643(a)(1)): door interlocks, source-exposed lights, viewing and intercom, emergency equipment, radiation monitors, timer, clock and decayed source activity; any failure locks the console off until it is fixed (35.643(d), (e)). During delivery no one but the patient is in the room (SSG-46 5.107), the patient is watched continuously (35.615(d)), opening the door retracts the source (35.615(b)), and anyone entering confirms with a monitor that radiation has returned to background (35.615(c)). HDR rooms carry permanently installed area monitors (SSG-46 5.155).
An emergency container large enough for the whole applicator, and a kit of long-handled forceps and clamps, sits close to the patient (SSG-46 5.135, 5.316; 35.615(g)). The manufacturer's one-page emergency procedure is posted at the console with the names and numbers of the responsible physician, physicist and radiation protection officer (35.610(a)(4), (b), (c)). If the source fails to return, the sequence escalates step by step: console retract, entry with a survey meter, retract at the unit, hand crank, survey, removal of the applicator into the emergency container, survey of patient and container, removal of the patient, notification (SSG-46 5.136). Because the response must happen within minutes, IAEA asks for a radiation oncologist, a medical physicist and a radiation therapy technologist to be immediately available during every HDR application (5.317); the US rule requires the authorised user and the authorised medical physicist to be physically present at the start of every HDR treatment, and a physicist with a trained physician throughout (35.615(f)(2)). Staff drill the procedure initially and at least yearly (35.610(e)). Afterwards the engineer inspects the unit, the physicist estimates the patient's dose and the radiation protection officer the staff doses, and the event is reported to the regulator where required and to a learning system such as SAFRON or ROSEIS (SSG-46 5.319).
The accident these rules answer is real: in a case recorded by the IAEA, staff disregarded an area monitor alarm because the console read 'safe', the source had broken off inside a catheter, the patient went home with it for almost four days and died, and 94 other people were exposed (SRS-17, event 84).
Why: The checks find a faulty door switch, light, monitor or timer before anyone is treated.
“The HDR/PDR afterloader should undergo routine quality assurance tests at the beginning of each treatment day”
International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018
Why: Each of these is a safety barrier; treating with one broken removes a layer of protection.
“If the results of the checks required in paragraph (d) of this section indicate the malfunction of any system, a licensee shall lock the control console in the off position and not use the unit except as may be necessary to repair, replace, or check the malfunctioning system.”
US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via eCFR) 2002
Why: If the source sticks, the applicator with the source inside is pulled out and put straight into the shielded container.
“The emergency container should be placed close to the patient and should be sufficiently large that it can accept the entire applicator assembly containing the source removed from the patient.”
International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018
Why: In an emergency there is no time to look for instructions or phone numbers.
“A copy of the procedures required by paragraph (a)(4) of this section must be physically located at the unit console.”
US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via eCFR) 2018
Why: In a recorded case the physicist picked up the wrong patient's chart at the console and the wrong programme was run.
“Insufficient safety provisions (defence in depth): There was no independent check of the information used for the treatment.”
Why: If the source sticks, the response has to happen within minutes, by people trained to do it.
“In HDR applications, the short response time (minutes) required for contingency actions imposes the need for the immediate availability of a radiological medical practitioner, a medical physicist and a medical radiation technologist during all applications.”
International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018
Why: Staff are protected by the shielded walls, and the patient is never out of sight or earshot.
“For external beam radiotherapy, HDR and PDR brachytherapy, no one should be in the treatment room during the delivery of treatment, except the patient being treated.”
International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018
Why: In a fatal accident the console read 'safe' while the source had broken off inside the patient; the alarm was right and was ignored.
“Staff ignored a monitor alarm and assumed that a 'safe' indication on the console was correct (previous false alarms of the external monitor contributed to this assumption).”
Why: Each step is quicker and safer than the next, and each survey shows whether the source is back in its safe.
“Manufacturers provide suggested emergency procedures to be implemented if the source fails to return to the safe.”
International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018
Why: The patient needs to know what dose they received, and other departments learn from the event.
“The medical physicist should make an assessment of the patient doses arising from the incident, and should check the machine for re-use after the engineer has completed the inspection and any associated maintenance.”
International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018
Why: A procedure used once in years is only reliable if it has been practised.
“A licensee shall ensure that operators, authorized medical physicists, and authorized users participate in drills of the emergency procedures, initially and at least annually.”
US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via eCFR) 2018
How care is usually carried out, read from the guidelines and standards cited. Your own team's protocol and their judgement come first; this page is for understanding it, not for doing it yourself.
A daily pre-treatment check of the afterloader and its room (IAEA SSG-46 5.134; 10 CFR 35.643), an emergency container and kit beside the patient (SSG-46 5.135; 35.615(g)), the manufacturer's escalating stuck-source procedure posted at the console (SSG-46 5.136; 35.610), continuous observation with no one else in the room, a monitor check on every entry, and annual drills (35.610(e); SSG-46 5.316). The two frameworks differ on staffing: IAEA asks for a radiation oncologist, a physicist and a radiation therapy technologist immediately available during all HDR applications; the US rule requires the authorised user and physicist to be physically present when each HDR treatment starts and a physicist with a trained physician to be present throughout. Neither grades its requirements: one is a safety standard and the other regulation, and the evidence behind both is the record of accidents.
International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018 · US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via eCFR) 2018 · US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via eCFR) 2002 · US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via eCFR) 2002 · International Atomic Energy Agency 2000
Where it differs: 10 CFR 35.615(f)(2) requires an authorised user and an authorised medical physicist to be physically present during the initiation of every HDR treatment, and a physicist plus an authorised user or trained physician to be physically present during its continuation. Medium and pulsed-dose-rate units need the physicist and a trained physician present at initiation and immediately available during continuation. The IAEA guide asks for immediate availability rather than physical presence.
Evidence: Regulation, not graded. Its rationale, the minutes available to act, is the one SSG-46 gives.
US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via eCFR) 2002 · International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018
Where it differs: Each afterloader's maker supplies its own single-page emergency sequence, which is what is posted at the console. IAEA gives the general order of steps; the unit's own card governs the details, such as where the emergency retract button and hand crank are.
Evidence: SSG-46 says these procedures are specific to the unit and assume the applicator is intact.
International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018
Where it differs: Sets out HDR procedures for staffing and training, treatment-specific quality assurance and emergency procedures, with an extensive quality assurance checklist. Only its abstract was read here.
Evidence: A professional consensus report; its content was not read beyond the abstract and no step rests on it.
American Association of Physicists in Medicine (Kubo et al., Medical Physics) 1998
| Recommendation | Grade, as printed | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Daily quality assurance tests of the HDR or PDR afterloader | Safety Guide recommendation (ungraded) | International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018 |
| Spot checks before the first HDR use each day, covering interlocks, lights, intercom, emergency equipment, monitors, timer, clock and source activity “Before the first use of a high dose-rate, medium dose-rate, or pulsed dose-rate remote afterloader unit on a given day;” | Regulatory requirement (ungraded) | US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via eCFR) 2002 |
| Emergency response equipment near each treatment room for a source left unshielded or lodged in the patient “A licensee shall have applicable emergency response equipment available near each treatment room to respond to a source—” | Regulatory requirement (ungraded) | US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via eCFR) 2002 |
| Anyone entering the room confirms with a monitor that radiation has returned to ambient levels “A licensee shall require any individual entering the treatment room to assure, through the use of appropriate radiation monitors, that radiation levels have returned to ambient levels.” | Regulatory requirement (ungraded) | US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (Code of Federal Regulations, via eCFR) 2002 |
| Staff trained on the stuck-source procedure and taking part in drills “Staff should be trained on how to apply such a procedure and should regularly participate in drills and exercises.” | Safety Guide recommendation (ungraded) | International Atomic Energy Agency, jointly sponsored by PAHO and WHO 2018 |
Shares Brachytherapy (internal radiotherapy), Remote afterloaders for HDR brachytherapy, Brachytherapy.
Shares Brachytherapy (internal radiotherapy), Brachytherapy.
Shares Brachytherapy (internal radiotherapy), Brachytherapy.
Shares Remote afterloaders for HDR brachytherapy, Brachytherapy.
Shares Brachytherapy, Cervical cancer.
Shares Brachytherapy, Cervical cancer.
Shares Brachytherapy, Cervical cancer.
Shares Brachytherapy, Cervical cancer.