Before an important appointment, a ready-made list of questions can help you ask what matters; in trials people asked more when the list came with an explanation or the clinician's encouragement. Afterwards, most people use a recording or written summary, and five of nine studies found they remembered more. No study read shows either changes how the illness goes, and findings on anxiety are mixed.
Prompt lists. A 2025 meta-analysis of 14 randomised trials in cancer found prompt lists increased questions asked (SMD 0.24, 95% CI 0.00 to 0.48) and engagement in shared decision making (SMD 0.33), with no significant effect on consultation length; lists given with instructions did better than lists alone (SMD 0.31 for questions asked), anxiety was slightly higher one week after use (SMD 0.17), and the authors rate the robustness of the pooled results for questions asked and consultation length as suboptimal. Earlier reviews disagree on how much this matters: Brandes 2015 called the interventions effective, Keinki 2021 found limited impact from a list alone, and the 2007 Cochrane review of 33 trials across healthcare concluded benefits were limited (question asking SMD 0.27). In advanced cancer, a review of seven trials (1059 participants) found more questions asked but no significant improvement in anxiety or quality of life.
Recordings and summaries. The 2008 Cochrane review (16 trials, 2318 adults with cancer) found 60 to 100 per cent used their recording or summary, five of nine studies reported better recall, three of ten more satisfaction and none an effect on anxiety or depression; it concluded that practitioners should consider offering them. A 2018 systematic review of 26 studies, not limited to cancer, found statistically significant support for several patient-reported outcomes, among them recall, anxiety and depression, while a 2019 overview of reviews judged the benefit of audio recording limited, and a 2021 trial in brain tumours (133 patients, under-powered) found patients felt better informed at one week but not at 3 or 6 months.
Guidance. NICE NG197 (2021), for all healthcare, recommends resources before a discussion that prompt questions, a letter written to the patient and resources afterwards on what was agreed (a printout is its example), and names encouraging a recording as one way to support people who need extra help. The BMA encourages UK doctors to support requests to record. The ASCO communication guideline could not be read in full. A person's own team and local policy on recording come first.
Why: NICE says the resource should encourage people to think about what matters to them, what they hope will happen as a result of the discussion, and what questions they would like to ask.
“Before a discussion, offer the person access to resources in their preferred format (for example, a booklet, flyer or app) to help them prepare for discussing options and making shared decisions.”
NICE 2021 · NICE recommendation 1.2.5 (2021), ungraded
Why: In the pooled trials, a list given with instructions (an explanation for the patient, or the clinician endorsing the list) increased the number of questions asked, and a list alone did not.
“QPL interventions with accompanying instructions showed superior effectiveness in promoting patient question-asking behavior and enhancing decision self-efficacy.”
Asia-Pacific Journal of Oncology Nursing (Han et al.) 2025 · systematic review and meta-analysis of 14 randomised trials
Why: NICE says including them can help the person take an active part in the discussion, explain what matters to them, make decisions, and remember the information given.
“Ask the person if they want to involve family members, friends, carers or advocates (being aware of safeguarding).”
NICE 2021 · NICE recommendation 1.2.3 (2021), ungraded
Why: NICE asks for this so that the person and the clinician decide together what matters most to discuss in the time there is.
“Agree an 'agenda' at the start of each discussion to prioritise together what to discuss. Say how long the discussion will last.”
NICE 2021 · NICE recommendation 1.2.7 (2021), ungraded
Why: In the trials, 60 to 100 per cent of people listened to the recording or read the summary at least once, 41.5 to 94.4 per cent used a recording to inform family and friends, and five of nine studies found better recall.
“Practitioners should consider offering people recordings or written summaries of their consultations.”
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (Pitkethly et al.) 2008 · Cochrane review of 16 controlled trials (2318 adults), authors' conclusion
Why: The BMA says most people record so they can listen again in a more relaxed setting or share the information with family and friends, and that patients whose doctors agree are less likely to record in secret.
“We encourage doctors to support patient requests to record their consultations.”
British Medical Association (a doctors' professional association and trade union) 2024 · professional association guidance (United Kingdom), ungraded
Why: The BMA, writing about the United Kingdom, says asking first is a matter of courtesy and respect and is more likely to lead to a trusting relationship, and that other patients have privacy rights. Rules differ in other countries.
“Both legally, and as a matter of courtesy, patients should seek doctors’ agreement before recording a consultation.”
British Medical Association (a doctors' professional association and trade union) 2024 · professional association guidance (United Kingdom), ungraded
Why: NICE names these as ways to help people who need extra help to take part in decisions. The BMA lists language barriers, distress, memory loss and complex information as situations where a recording helps.
“Offer additional support to people who are likely to need extra help to engage in shared decision making. This could include encouraging them to record the discussion, explaining in writing the decisions that have been made, or arranging follow up by a clinical member of staff or a suitable alternative.”
NICE 2021 · NICE recommendation 1.2.21 (2021), ungraded
Why: NICE says these resources are to help people understand what was discussed and agreed. The Cochrane review notes that many people find it difficult to remember information given in a consultation.
“This could be a printout summarising their diagnosis, the options and decisions or plans made, and links to high-quality online resources. Ideally, give people this material to take away, or provide it very soon after the discussion.”
NICE 2021 · NICE recommendation 1.2.18 (2021), ungraded
Why: NICE recommends writing the letter to the patient rather than to their healthcare professional, and that information given after a discussion says who to contact with further questions.
“Send a copy of the letter to the patient (unless they say they do not want a copy) and to the relevant healthcare professional.”
NICE 2021 · NICE recommendations 1.2.19 and 1.2.20 (2021), ungraded
How care is usually carried out, read from the guidelines and standards cited. Your own team's protocol and their judgement come first; this page is for understanding it, not for doing it yourself.
No cancer guideline that could be read sets out this procedure; the best-supported version combines NICE NG197 (2021, all healthcare, ungraded) with the trial evidence. Before a key appointment, offer a prompt list written for the situation and encourage its use: lists given with instructions increased questions asked in a meta-analysis of randomised trials in cancer, without a significant effect on consultation length, though its authors call the robustness of both results suboptimal. Afterwards, give a written summary and a letter addressed to the patient (NICE), and consider offering a recording (Cochrane 2008). The reviews disagree on how much benefit to expect, and both positions are shown. On prompt lists: Brandes 2015 concludes they "are effective in improving communication, psychological and cognitive outcomes", while Keinki 2021 finds that lists alone "show limited impact on communicative processes and psychological outcomes" and the Cochrane review of 33 trials across healthcare found "limited benefits to patients". On recordings: the Cochrane review says they "may benefit most adults with cancer" and Rieger 2018 calls them "valuable to patients and positively associated with patient-reported outcomes", while the 2019 overview of reviews states "There is limited benefit in audio recording consultations or using patient-held records during consultations." The reviews also disagree on anxiety: the Cochrane review of recordings found no difference in anxiety or depression in any of ten studies, Rieger 2018 reports statistically significant support for a beneficial effect on both, and one meta-analysis found slightly higher anxiety a week after a prompt list was used. No review read reports an effect on quality of life (the Cochrane review of recordings and the review in advanced cancer looked and found none), and the Cochrane review of recordings states that no study evaluated survival.
NICE 2021 · Asia-Pacific Journal of Oncology Nursing (Han et al.) 2025 · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (Kinnersley et al.) 2007 · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (Pitkethly et al.) 2008 · Psycho-Oncology (Brandes et al.) 2015 · Patient Education and Counseling (Keinki et al.) 2021 · Psycho-Oncology (Rieger et al.) 2018 · CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians (Licqurish et al.) 2019 · British Medical Association (a doctors' professional association and trade union) 2024
Where it differs: The list is handed over with no explanation; or someone explains it to the person before the consultation; or the clinician endorses it and invites the questions.
Evidence: Han 2025: across nine studies the pooled effect on questions asked was SMD 0.24 (95% CI 0.00 to 0.48); with instructions it was 0.31 (0.10 to 0.52) and for a list alone it was not significant. Decision self-efficacy improved only with instructions (SMD 0.45). The review rated five of its 16 articles at high risk of bias. The 2007 Cochrane review across healthcare found coaching and written materials had similar effects on question asking, and stated: "There appear to be no clear benefits from clinician training in addition to patient interventions, although the evidence is limited."
Asia-Pacific Journal of Oncology Nursing (Han et al.) 2025 · Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (Kinnersley et al.) 2007 · Psycho-Oncology (Brandes et al.) 2015
Where it differs: Instead of a list written for one situation, the organisation prompts everyone to ask three questions: what are my options, what are the possible benefits and risks, and how can we make a decision together that is right for me.
Evidence: NICE NG197 recommendation 1.1.16 gives these as examples for organisations to promote. No trial comparing the three questions with a cancer-specific prompt list was read.
Where it differs: A list written for people with advanced cancer, given before a consultation with the oncologist or palliative care doctor.
Evidence: Wang 2024: seven randomised trials, 1059 participants, six of them pooled; more questions asked (SMD 0.73, 95% CI 0.28 to 1.18) with "no significant improvements in health-related outcomes such as end of life, anxiety, and quality of life". In a US double-blind trial of a 25-item sheet against a general information sheet at a first palliative care visit (130 patients), the two were rated equally helpful (7.2 against 7.1 points), with no significant difference in anxiety, number of questions asked or consultation length; of the 47 patients asked at four weeks, 24 preferred the prompt sheet and 7 the general sheet.
Supportive Care in Cancer (Wang et al.) 2024 · JAMA Network Open (Arthur et al.) 2023
Where it differs: The service records the key consultation and gives the patient the audio file, rather than leaving it to the patient's phone.
Evidence: Cochrane 2008: between 60 and 100 per cent of participants in twelve studies listened or read at least once; 41.5 to 94.4 per cent in nine studies used it to inform family and friends. A scoping review of 33 studies found a weighted average of 72 per cent listened. In a Canadian trial in brain tumours (133 patients), those given the recording felt more fully informed at one week (p = 0.007) but not at 3 or 6 months, with no statistically significant difference in satisfaction, anxiety or depression; the authors note it was under-powered. Rieger 2018 lists the barriers: concerns about the strength of evidence, patient distress, effect on the consultation, clinic procedures, medico-legal issues and cost.
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (Pitkethly et al.) 2008 · Patient Education and Counseling (Tsulukidze et al.) 2014 · Supportive Care in Cancer (Hack et al.) 2021 · Psycho-Oncology (Rieger et al.) 2018
Where it differs: The patient or companion records with their own device, with the clinician's agreement. In the UK the BMA advises that patients should ask first, that no other patient may be recorded without explicit consent, and that NHS facilities will have local policies on recording devices.
Evidence: No trial of patient-made recordings was read. The BMA guidance (2024) states: "In some circumstances, permitting a patient to record a consultation, who may otherwise struggle to remember or understand, is likely to amount to a reasonable adjustment requirement under equality legislation." It also says that where a doctor remains unhappy, the consultation should not be refused unless a colleague willing to be recorded can see the patient safely and promptly. This is guidance from a doctors' association about UK law, not a clinical guideline.
British Medical Association (a doctors' professional association and trade union) 2024
Before a results or treatment-planning appointment, patients receive a list of good questions to ask, tailored to their situation, and can tick the ones they want covered.
Every cancer consultation is recorded with consent and the patient receives the audio plus a checked written summary of what was said and decided.
| Recommendation | Grade, as printed | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Prompt lists increased the number of questions asked by people with cancer “Nine studies reported the impact of interventions on the number of questions by patients with cancer.” | meta-analysis of 9 randomised trials: SMD 0.24, 95% CI 0.00 to 0.48, P = 0.05 | Asia-Pacific Journal of Oncology Nursing (Han et al.) 2025 |
| Interventions before consultations (33 trials, 8244 patients, all healthcare) produce small increases in question asking and satisfaction “Interventions before consultations designed to help patients address their information needs within consultations produce limited benefits to patients.” | Cochrane review (2007): question asking SMD 0.27, 95% CI 0.19 to 0.36 | Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (Kinnersley et al.) 2007 |
| Prompt lists alone have limited impact on communication and psychological outcomes “QPL-only interventions show limited impact on communicative processes and psychological outcomes.” | systematic review of 10 randomised trials | Patient Education and Counseling (Keinki et al.) 2021 |
| Prompt list interventions are effective for communication, psychological and cognitive outcomes “Question Prompt List interventions are effective in improving communication, psychological and cognitive outcomes of cancer patients.” | systematic review of 16 articles | Psycho-Oncology (Brandes et al.) 2015 |
| Recordings or summaries of key consultations may benefit most adults with cancer “The provision of recordings or summaries of key consultations may benefit most adults with cancer.” | Cochrane review of 16 controlled trials, 2318 adults (2008) | Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (Pitkethly et al.) 2008 |
| No effect of recordings or summaries on anxiety or depression “No studies (out of ten) found any statistically significant difference between groups in terms of anxiety or depression.” | Cochrane review (2008), 10 studies | Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews (Pitkethly et al.) 2008 |
| Consultation recordings are valuable to patients and associated with better patient-reported outcomes “Consultation recordings are valuable to patients and positively associated with patient-reported outcomes.” | systematic review of 26 studies (12 randomised trials) | Psycho-Oncology (Rieger et al.) 2018 |
| Limited benefit from audio recording consultations or patient-held records “There is limited benefit in audio recording consultations or using patient-held records during consultations.” | overview of 11 systematic reviews (84 primary studies) | CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians (Licqurish et al.) 2019 |
| Prompt lists increase questions without lengthening the consultation “Question prompt lists can increase the number of questions asked by patients without increasing consultation length and may encourage them to reflect and plan questions before the consultation.” | overview of 11 systematic reviews (84 primary studies) | CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians (Licqurish et al.) 2019 |
| Share the record of the discussion and decisions with the person “Offer to share this with the person, for example, in a post-clinic letter.” | NICE recommendation 1.2.17 (2021), ungraded | NICE 2021 |
Shares Consent and education before anticancer treatment, Distress screening with the distress thermometer, and referral by need, End of treatment: treatment summary, survivorship care plan and handover to primary care, American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and the tag protocol.
Shares End of treatment: treatment summary, survivorship care plan and handover to primary care, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and the tag protocol.
Shares End of treatment: treatment summary, survivorship care plan and handover to primary care, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and the tag protocol.
Shares National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and the tag protocol.
Shares National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and the tag protocol.
Shares National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and the tag protocol.
Shares National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and the tag protocol.
Shares National Institute for Health and Care Excellence and the tag protocol.