Cold caps were tested mostly in people with straight hair, and the one study in Black patients stopped early because the cap was not saving hair. The advice on preparing Afro-textured hair conflicts: wet it thoroughly, or keep it dry and straighten it first. A trial comparing preparation methods, with care instructions written for this hair type, would show whether the cap can be made to work.
The problem. A phase II feasibility study of Paxman scalp cooling in Black patients having chemotherapy for stage I to III breast cancer planned 30 patients and closed after 15 for lack of efficacy; its authors name hair thickness, hair volume and cap design as possible reasons. The Dutch registry study that found little value in wetting the hair was mainly in people with a European hair type and a high hair mass, and its authors found no convincing evidence either way.
The conflicting advice. The manufacturer's guide tells people with curly and coily hair to make sure the hair is wet before the cap goes on and not to straighten or relax it. The authors of a 2026 interview study of 17 Black women write that women with natural hair should avoid excess wetting and instead straighten the hair and apply emollients, while noting the time, fatigue and heat damage this involves. Women in that study said the instructions and the conditioner supplied were not written for their hair and described their own changes, such as cutting the hair short or using gel.
What is not known. No trial has compared any preparation method or hair care regimen during scalp cooling, in any hair type. Whether a different cap design matters more than preparation is also untested.
Shares Hair loss and scalp cooling with breast cancer chemotherapy, Fund scalp cooling and hair-preserving measures for every alopecia-inducing regimen, Scalp cooling (cold caps: DigniCap, Paxman) and the tag protocol-upgrade.
Shares the tags protocol-upgrade, upgrade:untested.
Shares the tags protocol-upgrade, upgrade:untested.
Shares the tags protocol-upgrade, upgrade:untested.
Shares the tags protocol-upgrade, upgrade:untested.
Shares the tags protocol-upgrade, upgrade:untested.
Shares the tags protocol-upgrade, upgrade:untested.
Shares the tags protocol-upgrade, upgrade:untested.
Every source this page cites, grouped by who published it. Grouping is read from the web address, not assigned by hand.
A source that has moved or gone is reported by the weekly link check. /audit/