In the UK, a ReSPECT plan records what matters to you and which treatments are recommended in an emergency when you cannot speak for yourself, including whether resuscitation (CPR) should be tried. It is made in conversation with you, or those close to you. It is a recommendation, not legally binding. A decision not to attempt resuscitation covers resuscitation only; all other care continues.
This page explains how these conversations and forms are meant to work in the UK, so that patients and families know what to expect and what to ask; your own team's policy and local forms come first. The joint BMA, Resuscitation Council UK and RCN guidance (3rd edition, 1st revision, 2016) sets the rules for any decision about cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR): decisions are individual, never blanket; they are best made ahead of a crisis within wider planning; there is a presumption in favour of involving the person, and a conversation may be delayed or avoided only where it is likely to cause them physical or psychological harm; where CPR has no realistic prospect of success the decision is a clinical one that does not need consent but there must be a presumption in favour of explaining it to the person; where CPR might work, the balance of benefit and burden is not solely a clinical decision and calls for open dialogue and shared decision making; a valid and applicable advance refusal must be respected; a person who lacks capacity has the decision made in their best interests (in Scotland, their benefit) after consulting those close to them, who help the team decide and do not decide themselves unless they hold legal authority; the most senior clinician responsible carries overall responsibility; a second opinion is offered on disagreement; and the decision is documented, reviewed and travels with the person. A DNACPR decision applies only to CPR. ReSPECT (Resuscitation Council UK, version 3 of the form) sets the CPR recommendation inside a summary plan: a shared understanding of the person's health, what matters to them, an agreed focus of care between extending life and comfort, specific recommendations in plain words, the CPR recommendation, capacity, who was involved, clinicians' signatures, emergency contacts and review. The plan is not legally binding, is not an advance decision to refuse treatment, cannot be used to demand treatment, and may recommend that CPR is attempted. The 2016 guidance gives average survival to discharge after CPR as 15 to 20 per cent in most hospitals and usually 5 to 10 per cent outside hospital, and stresses that these are averages across everyone in whom CPR was tried: an individual's chance could range from zero to almost 100 per cent depending on the cause and circumstances. The GMC's guidance on resuscitation decisions and NHS England's Universal Principles for Advance Care Planning could not be read, because both sites refused a script.
Why: Without a decision made ahead of time, the default in an emergency is to attempt resuscitation, including for people it could not help or who would not have wanted it.
“Considering explicitly, and whenever possible making specific anticipatory decisions about, whether or not to attempt CPR is an important part of good-quality care for any person who is approaching the end of life and/or is at risk of cardiorespiratory arrest.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 1)
Why: The guidance says these decisions are best made before a crisis forces a hurried one in an emergency setting.
“For many people, anticipatory decisions about CPR are best made in the wider context of advance care planning, before a crisis necessitates a hurried decision in an emergency setting.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 3)
Why: The plan is meant to record what the person wants and what is realistic for them, which cannot be known without asking.
“Do not complete the plan without maximum possible involvement of the person in the process (or of those best able to speak for them if they do not have capacity for involvement).”
Resuscitation Council UK 2023 · Not graded (ReSPECT guide, before you start)
Why: In the guide, the goal of care and the recommendations follow from this shared view of the person's conditions and how they may progress.
“Discuss, explain and achieve a shared understanding of the person’s relevant health conditions and how these may progress or change.”
Resuscitation Council UK 2023 · Not graded (ReSPECT guide, section 2)
Why: Some people want every treatment that might lengthen life, some want comfort above all, and many want a balance; only the person can say which.
“Summarise what the person says would matter most to them (values and fears), both in daily life and as an outcome of future emergency treatment.”
Resuscitation Council UK 2023 · Not graded (ReSPECT guide, section 3)
Why: The guide says to avoid jargon and use wording easily understood by all who may respond to an emergency in any health or care setting.
“Following from clinical understanding and the values and fears agreed in sections 2 and 3, establish an agreed overall goal of care, and sign one of the three boxes:”
Resuscitation Council UK 2023 · Not graded (ReSPECT guide, section 4)
Why: Whether the chance of benefit is worth the risk of harm is the person's judgement to make, not only the doctor's.
“For a patient with capacity there should be open dialogue and shared decision-making between the patient and professionals, unless the patient declines any such discussion.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (section 6)
Why: Consent to such a decision is not needed, but the guidance sets a presumption in favour of explaining it. The NHS website says that in England the law gives you the right to be involved in, and informed of, the decision.
“Even when CPR has no realistic prospect of success, there must be a presumption in favour of explaining the need and basis for a DNACPR decision to a patient, or to those close to a patient who lacks capacity.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 10)
Why: The guidance calls blanket policies for groups, such as everyone in a nursing home or over a certain age, unethical and probably unlawful; the NHS website for England says such decisions are unlawful.
“Every decision about CPR must be made on the basis of a careful assessment of each individual’s situation. These decisions should never be dictated by ‘blanket’ policies.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 4)
Why: Adults are assumed to have capacity unless there is clear evidence to the contrary. The law on what must happen when capacity is lacking differs between England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.
“If the person lacks capacity for a specific decision, or they cannot have capacity (e.g. they are unconscious), the decision must be made by following the requirements of capacity legislation.”
Resuscitation Council UK 2023 · Not graded (ReSPECT guide, section 5)
Why: Family and friends know the person's wishes; unless they hold legal authority they help the team decide rather than carry the weight of deciding.
“Those close to the patient must be consulted about CPR decisions that are made on a balance of benefits and risks, in particular to determine any previously expressed wishes and what level or chance of recovery or risk the patient would have been likely to consider acceptable.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (section 10.1)
Why: The guidance calls it well established in law and ethics that an adult with capacity may refuse any treatment, even if that results in their death. Advance decisions are covered by statute in England and Wales only; for Scotland and Northern Ireland the 2016 guidance says they are likely to be binding under common law.
“If a patient with capacity refuses CPR, or a patient lacking capacity has a valid and applicable advance decision to refuse treatment (ADRT), specifically refusing CPR, this must be respected.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 8)
Why: Resuscitation Council UK says the professional signs to confirm their responsibility for following the ReSPECT process and capacity and human rights law; the person's signature shows they took part and does not make the plan legally binding.
“As the professional who completed the ReSPECT plan, you must sign this section and record the date and time.”
Resuscitation Council UK 2023 · Not graded (ReSPECT guide, section 7)
Why: The form is a summary, and the guidance says the health record often needs detail beyond it. Recording a plan to involve the person or their family as soon as possible is from the ReSPECT clinicians' guide (section 6).
“Clear and full documentation of decisions about CPR, the reasons for them, and the discussions that informed those decisions, is an essential part of high-quality care.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 19)
Why: The guidance calls it a common fear among the public that a DNACPR decision will lead to other treatment being withheld; all other appropriate treatment and care should continue.
“It is essential that healthcare professionals, patients and those close to patients understand that a decision not to attempt CPR applies only to CPR and not to any other element of care or treatment.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 16)
Why: The guidance says a second opinion should be offered; where every member of a multidisciplinary team has endorsed the decision, a further opinion may not be needed.
“Where a patient or those close to a patient disagree with a DNACPR decision a second opinion should be offered.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 12)
Why: Resuscitation Council UK's guidance for people with a plan says to keep it somewhere easy to find and to make sure family or carers know where it is, in case you cannot reach it yourself in an emergency.
“Recorded decisions about CPR should accompany a patient when they move from one setting to another.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 22)
Why: A decision made during one illness may not fit a recovery, a relapse or a change of mind.
“Triggers for review should include any request from the patient or those close to them, any substantial change in the patient’s clinical condition or prognosis and transfer of the patient to a different location (including transfer within a healthcare establishment).”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 6)
Why: The plan guides the professionals on the spot, who make the final decision; Resuscitation Council UK says they should have valid reasons for not following a plan's recommendations. The guidance adds that where nothing is recorded but a person is in the advanced stages of a terminal illness and resuscitation would not succeed, a carefully considered decision not to start it should be supported.
“Where no explicit decision about CPR has been considered and recorded in advance there should be an initial presumption in favour of CPR.”
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Not graded (main message 24)
How care is usually carried out, read from the guidelines and standards cited. Your own team's protocol and their judgement come first; this page is for understanding it, not for doing it yourself.
A resuscitation decision made ahead of a crisis, with the person, on their individual situation, explained even where the clinician judges that resuscitation would not work, documented with its reasons, reviewed on request, on a change in condition and on a move between settings, portable across services, and understood by everyone to apply to resuscitation alone. That is what the joint BMA, Resuscitation Council UK and RCN guidance (2016) sets out; it does not grade its statements and is under review. The GMC's guidance for doctors, which covers the same ground, could not be read. Where the sources differ is the form the decision is recorded on. The first position is a standalone DNACPR form, which the 2016 guidance was written around and which Wales uses under an all-Wales policy. The second is an emergency care and treatment plan that sets the resuscitation recommendation inside the person's overall goals of care: ReSPECT, which Resuscitation Council UK recommends as the single plan for all ages in England, or another local tool (the NHS website names treatment escalation plans, and Resuscitation Council UK notes that much of London uses the Universal Care Plan). The evidence for the second position is observational. An NIHR evidence synthesis (2016) found about 1,500 incidents involving DNACPR decisions reported a year, a third of them reporting harm, and found that linking the decision to an overall treatment plan improved clarity and reduced harms. A before-and-after study of one such plan in one acute hospital (the Universal Form of Treatment Options) found fewer harmful events in patients with a decision not to attempt resuscitation (a rate difference of 12.9 per 1,000 patient-days). The NIHR evaluation of ReSPECT itself (England, 2017 to 2020) found patient or family involvement recorded on 513 of 706 forms reviewed (73 per cent), harms on the NHS Safety Thermometer similar with and without a form, and conversations that ranged from open-ended to simply informing the patient of a decision already made; its authors say incomplete adoption limited what could be concluded about outcomes. No randomised trial of either approach was found.
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · Resuscitation Council UK 2023 · Resuscitation Council UK 2026 · Resuscitation Council UK 2026 · NHS website (England), patient information 2023 · NIHR Health Services and Delivery Research (Perkins et al.) 2016 · PLoS One (Fritz et al.) 2013 · NIHR Journals Library (Perkins et al.) 2022
Where it differs: Resuscitation Council UK's guidance for people with a plan answers three common questions. It is not legally binding: "they should have valid reasons for not following the recommendations on a ReSPECT plan" and "The ReSPECT plan is not an Advance Decision to Refuse Treatment (ADRT)." It is not the same as a DNACPR form: "It includes a recommendation about CPR, but that may be a recommendation that CPR is attempted, or a recommendation that it is not attempted." And its patient page says "the ReSPECT plan cannot be used to demand treatments that are not likely to benefit you and would not be offered."
Evidence: The form's owner describing its own form. A person in England or Wales who wants a refusal of resuscitation to be legally binding needs an advance decision to refuse treatment that meets the Mental Capacity Act 2005, sections 24 to 26; the NHS website says the same of a DNACPR form.
Resuscitation Council UK 2025 · Resuscitation Council UK 2026 · UK Parliament (legislation.gov.uk); extends to England and Wales 2005 · NHS website (England), patient information 2023
Where it differs: Records only the decision not to attempt resuscitation, on a form recognised locally or nationally. The NHS website says such a form "can be written for a short period" or "with no end date", that the person should be told when it will be reviewed, and that a decision made in hospital is included in the discharge summary and shared with the GP. Wales has had an all-Wales DNACPR policy for adults since 2015.
Evidence: The NIHR evidence synthesis (2016) found variation and suboptimal practice across settings, and across its focus groups a "negative impact on overall patient care of having a DNACPR decision and the conflation of ‘do not resuscitate’ with ‘do not provide active treatment’". The All Wales policy itself was not read.
NHS website (England), patient information 2023 · Resuscitation Council UK 2026 · NIHR Health Services and Delivery Research (Perkins et al.) 2016 · BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016
Where it differs: In England and Wales a person who lacks capacity has the decision made in their best interests under the Mental Capacity Act 2005, after consulting anyone they named, their carers and others interested in their welfare; the NHS website (England) says an attorney under a lasting power of attorney that covers life-sustaining treatment can make the decision about CPR in the person's best interests but cannot insist on CPR being given, while the 2016 joint guidance says only that it is likely, though untested in the courts, that such an attorney can decide that CPR should not be attempted. In Scotland the test is benefit under the Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 2000, with a welfare attorney or guardian. For Northern Ireland the 2016 joint guidance says statutory provision "has not been implemented yet; it is nonetheless good practice to discuss decision-making with those close to the patient", and that the Mental Capacity Act (Northern Ireland) passed in 2016 awaited its code of practice. Advance decisions to refuse treatment are statutory in England and Wales only; the joint guidance says that in Scotland and Northern Ireland "it is likely that they are binding under common law".
Evidence: Statute and professional guidance. The joint guidance dates from 2016; the Scottish and Northern Irish Acts were not read, the Northern Irish position may have moved since, and the GMC guidance that would give a later statement could not be read.
BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 · UK Parliament (legislation.gov.uk); extends to England and Wales 2005 · NHS website (England), patient information 2023
Where it differs: National POLST describes its form as "a portable medical order for patients who have a progressing serious illness or frailty due to aging". Unlike a ReSPECT plan, which is a recommendation that the person need not sign, "Since the POLST form is a medical order, it should be completed and signed by you and your doctor." It covers resuscitation, hospital transfer, intensive care and ventilation, and tube feeding, is run state by state under different names, and sits beside an advance directive, which is the legal document that names a decision maker.
Evidence: A systematic review (20 observational studies, 104,554 patients, 27,090 with POLST) found no randomised trials, moderate-strength evidence that treatment limitations on POLST may reduce treatment intensity at the end of life, and that in acute care a sizable number of patients likely received care that did not match their POLST. The two systems have not been compared with each other in any source read.
National POLST (United States) 2026 · Journal of the American Geriatrics Society (Vranas et al.) 2021 · Resuscitation Council UK 2025
Where it differs: Where a planned procedure could itself cause an arrest that prompt treatment would probably reverse, such as cardiac catheterisation, pacemaker insertion or an operation, the joint guidance says the decision should be reviewed beforehand and discussed with the patient, or their representative, as part of consent to the procedure: "Some patients may wish a DNACPR decision to remain valid despite the risk of a cardiorespiratory arrest from a reversible cause; others will request that the DNACPR decision is suspended temporarily." When the decision will be reinstated is agreed in advance and documented.
Evidence: Professional guidance (section 7.3); not graded.
| Recommendation | Grade, as printed | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Overall responsibility for a resuscitation decision rests with the most senior clinician responsible for the person's care, as local policy defines; this could be a consultant, a GP or a suitably experienced nurse “The overall clinical responsibility for decisions about CPR, including DNACPR decisions, rests with the most senior clinician responsible for the person’s care as defined explicitly by local policy.” | Not graded (section 14) | BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 |
| A resuscitation decision form is not legally binding “A CPR decision form in itself is not legally binding.” | Not graded (main message 20) | BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 |
| Consent is not needed for a decision not to attempt resuscitation that has no realistic prospect of success; there must still be a presumption in favour of explaining it “It is not necessary to obtain the consent of a patient or of those close to a patient to a decision not to attempt CPR that has no realistic prospect of success.” | Not graded (main message 10) | BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 |
| Those close to a patient who lacks capacity help the team decide; they do not take the decision unless they hold legal authority “it should be made clear to those close to the patient that their role is not to take decisions on behalf of the patient, but to help the healthcare team to make an appropriate decision in the patient’s best interests.” | Not graded (section 10) | BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 |
| A conversation may be delayed or avoided only where it is likely to cause the patient physical or psychological harm “A decision to delay or avoid communication of a decision to a patient must be based on that communication being likely to cause the patient physical or psychological harm.” | Not graded (main message 14) | BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 |
| A DNACPR decision does not override clinical judgement where an arrest has a reversible cause that was not envisaged, such as choking “A DNACPR decision does not override clinical judgement in the unlikely event of a reversible cause of the person’s respiratory or cardiac arrest that does not match the circumstances envisaged when that decision was made and recorded.” | Not graded (main message 17) | BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 |
| Decisions must be free from discrimination, for example on grounds of disability “Decisions about CPR must be free from any discrimination, for example in respect of a disability.” | Not graded (main message 18) | BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 |
| A recommendation not to attempt CPR must be discussed with the person unless it would cause physiological or psychological harm, with the reasons documented “Remember that clinicians must discuss a recommendation not to attempt CPR with the person concerned, unless it is thought that it will cause physiological or psychological harm; if you believe this is so, you must document your reasons in section 6 and in the person’s health record.” | Not graded (ReSPECT guide, section 4) | Resuscitation Council UK 2023 |
| Signatures of the person or those close to them are optional and do not make the plan legally binding “Their signatures are optional. They do not make the plan legally binding.” | Not graded (ReSPECT guide, section 8) | Resuscitation Council UK 2023 |
| The person must be told that a DNACPR form has been or will be completed, though consent is not needed (England, patient information) “You must be told that a DNACPR form will be/has been completed for you, but a doctor does not need your consent.” | Not graded (NHS website) | NHS website (England), patient information 2023 |
| Decisions for groups of people at once are unlawful (England, patient information) “DNACPR decisions should not be made for a group of people at once.” | Not graded (NHS website) | NHS website (England), patient information 2023 |
| Average survival to discharge after in-hospital cardiac arrest where CPR is attempted “In most hospitals the average survival to discharge is in the range of 15-20%.” | Not graded (section 1; an average, as cited in the 2016 guidance) | BMA, Resuscitation Council UK, RCN 2016 |
| ReSPECT evaluation in England, 2017 to 2020: use and involvement “Involvement of the patient and/or family was recorded on 513 of 706 (73%) ReSPECT forms reviewed.” | Mixed-methods evaluation (observational) | NIHR Journals Library (Perkins et al.) 2022 |
| ReSPECT evaluation: harms “The frequency of harms reported on the NHS Safety Thermometer was similar among patients with or without a ReSPECT form.” | Mixed-methods evaluation (observational) | NIHR Journals Library (Perkins et al.) 2022 |
| Linking DNACPR to an overall treatment plan improved clarity and reduced harms “Linking DNACPR to overall treatment plans improved clarity about goals of care, aided communication and reduced harms.” | Evidence synthesis (systematic review and NHS data) | NIHR Health Services and Delivery Research (Perkins et al.) 2016 |
| POLST: strength of evidence “We found moderate strength of evidence that treatment limitations on POLST may reduce treatment intensity among patients with serious illness.” | Moderate strength of evidence (systematic review of observational studies) | Journal of the American Geriatrics Society (Vranas et al.) 2021 |
Shares Palliative sedation for refractory suffering at the end of life, Advance care planning, Strong opioids for cancer pain: starting, titrating, rescue doses and preventing constipation, Care in the last days of life: recognising dying, hydration, symptom control and anticipatory medicines.
Shares Advance care planning, Early integrated palliative care.
Shares Hospice and end-of-life care, Early integrated palliative care.
Shares Advance care planning, Early integrated palliative care.
Shares Palliative sedation for refractory suffering at the end of life, Care in the last days of life: recognising dying, hydration, symptom control and anticipatory medicines, Hospice and end-of-life care, Early integrated palliative care.
Shares Palliative sedation for refractory suffering at the end of life, Care in the last days of life: recognising dying, hydration, symptom control and anticipatory medicines, Hospice and end-of-life care, Early integrated palliative care.
Shares Strong opioids for cancer pain: starting, titrating, rescue doses and preventing constipation, Care in the last days of life: recognising dying, hydration, symptom control and anticipatory medicines, Hospice and end-of-life care.
Shares Palliative sedation for refractory suffering at the end of life, Care in the last days of life: recognising dying, hydration, symptom control and anticipatory medicines, Early integrated palliative care.