Not enough oncologists, nurses, pathologists, physicists
The number of people with cancer is rising faster than the workforce trained to treat them.
Cancer incidence is rising with ageing populations while the workforce that delivers care is growing slowly, ageing itself and burning out. ASCO projected a shortfall of more than 2,000 US oncologists by 2025; the US and Canadian pathologist workforce shrank by about a sixth between 2007 and 2017 while case complexity rose; radiotherapy physicists, radiation therapists and oncology nurses are short even in wealthy systems; and in many low- and middle-income countries a single oncologist serves thousands of new patients a year. Training pipelines take a decade, maldistribution concentrates specialists in cities, and burnout affects around half of oncologists. Every other bottleneck, from trial enrolment to genomic testing to palliative care, is rate-limited by people. Task-shifting, advanced practice roles, AI triage and reporting, tele-oncology and international training programmes are the levers.
- Specialist training takes ten or more years and training places have not expanded with demand.
- Ageing of the workforce and early retirement, accelerated by burnout, remove capacity faster than it is replaced.
- Specialists concentrate in cities and high-income countries, leaving rural and poor regions unserved.
- Administrative burden, electronic record documentation and prior authorisation consume clinical time.
- Pathology and physics are under-recruited because they are less visible and, in some systems, less well paid.
- The NHS Long Term Workforce Plan (2023) commits to expanding training places, including in oncology and diagnostics.
- The WHO Global Strategy on Human Resources for Health: Workforce 2030 sets targets for health workforce density.
- AI tools for mammography triage (Lunit, and the MASAI trial), pathology screening (Paige, PathAI) and radiotherapy auto-contouring extend the reach of scarce specialists.
- Advanced practice providers and oncology pharmacists take on follow-up, toxicity management and survivorship visits.
- The ESMO/ASCO Global Curriculum and the IAEA training programmes standardise oncology and physics training internationally.
- Project ECHO and tele-oncology models connect community clinicians to specialist centres for case review.
There are far too few genetic counsellors. A validated chatbot can do the standard pre-test education, leaving people with complex needs for humans.
Malnutrition is the commonest untreated complication in cancers of the gut, throat and pancreas. Putting a dietitian in the meeting where treatment is decided means it is seen and treated before chemotherapy starts, not after weight has been lost.
AI tools that write clinic notes are spreading fast in cancer clinics. Test them properly: do they save time, do they make mistakes about drugs and doses, and do patients notice a difference?
Test head to head whether an AI that reads the record and the evidence recommends treatments as well as a panel of experts, and whether patients do as well.
Rare cancers are often misdiagnosed, which sends patients down the wrong treatment path. Digital slide sharing could get every case to an expert within days.
Radiation therapists, the staff who deliver daily treatment, can be trained to outline normal organs on scans and to review patients during treatment, work that oncologists now do.
Most screening CT scans are normal. Letting a validated AI clear them, and sending only flagged scans to a radiologist, would let screening scale without more radiologists.
Let validated AI make the first read on routine, high-volume samples like cervical smears and standard breast biopsy stains, so scarce pathologists spend their time on the difficult cases.
Oncologists spend hours a day typing notes. Software that listens to the consultation and drafts the note, the letter and the orders could return that time to seeing patients.
Training a specialist doctor takes ten years or more. Mid-level clinicians can be trained in eighteen months to run protocol-based cancer care under supervision, and there are far more of them.
No one knows exactly how many oncologists, nurses, physicists and pathologists each country has or needs. A public, regularly updated model would let governments plan training and spot shortfalls years ahead.
Millions of community health workers already visit homes for vaccines and maternal care. Training them to recognise cancer warning signs, guide patients through the system and support home pain care would reach people no hospital does.
Pharmacies are everywhere and open late. They could give HPV vaccines, hand out bowel test kits, run stop-smoking clinics and offer HPV self-sampling under one roof.
Thousands of oncologists trained in poorer countries now work abroad. A structured programme could let them join weekly video case conferences for hospitals back home, improving decisions at almost no cost.
Many countries have one oncologist for millions of people. Train nurses and general doctors to deliver protocolised cancer care with software checks and remote specialist oversight.
Make the first project of every doctoral student a careful, published attempt to repeat an important result. Students learn rigour, and the field gets thousands of replications a year.
Cancer is an evolving population, but treatment decisions are rarely made with an evolutionary biologist present. Add one to the weekly meeting and see whether decisions change.
Trained cancer doctors and nurses who have fled conflict or moved countries often spend years unable to practise. A short, competency-based route back to work would add capacity quickly.
Patients are more likely to join a trial when the doctor offering it looks like them or works in their community. Funding more such doctors to become trial leaders would change who is enrolled.
Almost no surgeons or radiation oncologists have time or funding to do research. Dedicated training awards with protected time would build the workforce that surgical and radiotherapy trials need.
Doctors who could turn discoveries into trials are buried in clinical work. Hospitals would guarantee them research time and recover the cost from the trials and grants they bring in.
Uganda makes liquid morphine from powder in a simple facility and lets trained nurses prescribe it, giving pain relief to patients that no doctor will ever reach. Other countries could copy this within a year.
When a trial changes the standard of care, every oncologist would receive a five-minute, case-based lesson within a month, rather than waiting for the next conference.
Trained nurses following strict written protocols can safely run chemotherapy clinics for common cancers, with an oncologist available by video for decisions and problems.
Most follow-up visits after successful treatment are routine. Nurse practitioners can run them well, giving survivors more time and oncologists more capacity for new patients.
A phone app that works without internet and guides a general doctor or nurse through diagnosing and treating common cancers with the drugs actually available locally.
Let specially trained cancer pharmacists prescribe anti-sickness drugs, growth-factor support and routine dose adjustments under protocols, freeing oncologists for decisions only they can make.
There are too few genetic counsellors to see every patient who should have an inherited-risk test. Let the cancer team order the test with a short consent script, and use video counsellors for those with results that matter.
Medical physicists, who keep radiotherapy machines accurate and safe, are scarcer than oncologists in many countries. Remote quality checks with local technologists could let one physicist safely oversee several machines.
Train and pay people who have been through cancer to guide newly diagnosed patients through the system, especially where oncologists and nurses are scarce.
Much of a pathologist's day is preparation, measuring and describing specimens. Trained assistants can do that, and AI can pre-screen slides, so each pathologist reports far more cancers.
Project ECHO is a weekly video class where district doctors and nurses present real cases to a specialist team, learn by doing, and build a network. It worked for hepatitis C and could work for cancer.
Half of cancer patients need radiotherapy and most of the world cannot get it. Commit to low-cost machines, automated planning and trained staff so that access is universal by 2040.
Rather than sending a handful of trainees to Europe or America, build a few large training centres in Africa and South Asia that train the whole team together, with local case mix and local costs.
Many cancer specialists trained in poor countries emigrate. Combine service bonds, salary supplements, guaranteed working equipment and academic time so that staying is a career, not a sacrifice.
Not every survivor needs to see an oncologist every six months for years. Sort people by recurrence risk, send low-risk survivors back to their family doctor with a clear plan, and guarantee rapid return if something changes.
Sweden's MASAI trial showed AI can safely replace one of two radiologists. Rolling it out region by region in a randomised order would prove it works at national scale and that interval cancers do not rise.
Hospitals without enough physicists could upload scans to a shared planning centre, where AI drafts the treatment plan and remote experts finish and check it within a day.
Hospitals rarely know which step, the scanner, the biopsy, the pathologist or the clinic slot, is causing the queue. Modelling the pathway like a factory line shows where a small change would remove weeks of waiting.
Many countries have one pathologist per million people. Putting a slide scanner in each district lab and sending images to a pooled group of pathologists could give a cancer diagnosis in days instead of months.
Surgery cures more cancers than any other treatment, but most district hospitals refer everything to a distant centre. Train and mentor general surgeons to do common cancer operations well, with specialists checking results.
Give the nurses and pharmacists who take patients' calls a tool that walks them through recognising and managing side effects of modern cancer drugs, including when to escalate.
Give oncologists and cancer nurses the training, time and production support to reach people where they actually get information, on social video and podcasts.
Postdocs who discover something promising usually have to leave it behind when their contract ends. A fellowship would pay them for two years to turn it into a candidate drug or diagnostic, with mentors from industry.
Drawing targets and planning radiotherapy takes hours of scarce expert time. Properly tested AI could do much of it, letting the same staff treat far more patients, if regulators and payers set clear rules for proving and paying for it.
A large trial showed that palliative care delivered by video works as well as in person for people with advanced lung cancer. Payers should cover it so that distance from a hospital no longer decides who gets it.
In Kerala, trained community volunteers, backed by nurses and doctors, provide most home palliative care to the dying. The model reaches more people at lower cost than any clinic-based service and could be copied.
AI can take over one reader's work in double-reading screening programmes while finding more cancers. Whether the extra cancers found are ones that would have harmed women, and whether interval cancers fall, is the question the trial's primary endpoint will answer.
Men with metastatic castration-resistant prostate cancer that has progressed after hormonal therapy and chemotherapy, and whose tumours show PSMA on a PET scan, can now receive lutetium-PSMA, which extends life, controls pain and is usually better tolerated than further chemotherapy. It has established a new treatment class in which a scan decides who gets the matching radioactive drug, and it is now being tested earlier in the disease (PSMAfore, PSMAddition).
Palliative care is not what happens when treatment stops; it works best alongside cancer treatment from the start. Patients feel better, are less depressed and may live longer. Access remains the constraint: most of the world's patients never see a palliative care specialist.
Pages like this
not linked directly; found by shared links- BottleneckMost of the world has almost no cancer care
Shares Retention packages so trained oncology staff stay: bonds, top-ups, working equipment, An 18-month oncology track for clinical officers and physician associates, Credentialed diaspora oncologists staffing remote tumour boards for home-country hospitals, Project ECHO tele-mentoring for district clinicians managing cancer.
- BottleneckAI that is built but not validated or deployed
Shares A randomised trial of AI scribes in oncology clinics measuring errors and time, Double oncology capacity in low-resource settings with task-shifting and AI decision support, Pathologist assistants plus AI triage to multiply pathologist capacity, A randomised trial of AI-generated treatment recommendations versus tumour boards.
- BottleneckPain relief and palliative care are unavailable to most
Shares Video palliative care as an equivalent default option for patients far from a team, Volunteer-led neighbourhood palliative networks, the Kerala model, adapted elsewhere, Locally prepared oral morphine solution, licensed for nurse prescribing, Community health workers trained in cancer triage, navigation and home palliative care.
- BottleneckKnowledge reaches practice too slowly
Shares Credentialed diaspora oncologists staffing remote tumour boards for home-country hospitals, Project ECHO tele-mentoring for district clinicians managing cancer, Micro-learning pushed to community oncologists within 30 days of a practice change, A randomised trial of AI-generated treatment recommendations versus tumour boards.
- BottleneckFragmented care and guideline gaps
Shares Simulate each hospital's cancer pathway as a queue to find and remove the waits, Oncology pharmacists as protocol prescribers for supportive care and dose adjustments, NCI-Designated Cancer Centers, European Cancer Organisation.